Sicilian-style pizza, gluten-free options, and a relaxed room
Neighborhood pizza on West Utica Street in Buffalo, NY, with dine-in seating, takeout, gluten-free pizza, and a tip-free staff.
Reviewers describe the restaurant as tip free, with staff who are friendly and attentive.
A gluten-free pizza is on the menu, and one reviewer said it was well made and came out quickly.
Guests describe the decor as vintage and the atmosphere as relaxed and cute.
The bar offers a wine selection and beer, and staff help guests pick what to drink.
Extra Extra Pizza is a pizza restaurant at 549 W Utica St in Buffalo, NY. Guests can sit in or take their order to go. Reviewers mention Sicilian-style pizzas, including a banana pepper and bread crumb version, and a gluten-free pizza that arrived quickly.
The dining room has a vintage look and a relaxed feel, and the bar offers beer and wine with staff to help guests choose. The restaurant is tip free, and several reviewers say the staff are friendly and attentive. Bread is served on the house when the wait for a table runs long.
Pizzas in the Sicilian style, such as the banana pepper and bread crumb pie.
A gluten-free pizza option for guests who avoid gluten.
Sit down in a vintage dining room with a relaxed atmosphere.
Order to go and eat the pizza at home.
A wine selection and beer served at the bar.
Bread served free while guests wait for a table during busy times.
“My new favorite pizza place, and that's saying a lot with the pizza places in Buffalo. Great food, the space is so cute, great wine selection and the staff were absolutely fantastic.”
“Stopped in when my mom was in town on a random afternoon. Both of us are gluten free. The gluten free pizza was delicious, well made, and came quickly.”
“Last night Shannon and I had dinner at Extra Extra Pizza and it was outstanding. We sat at the bar and Bridget took care of us all night. She was amazing. Super friendly, knowledgeable, and honestly made the whole experience even better.”
Extra Extra Pizza is at 549 W Utica St, Buffalo, NY 14213, United States. Use the map on this page for directions.
Opening hours: Monday 5–9 pm; Tuesday 5–9 pm; Wednesday 5–9 pm; Thursday 5–9 pm; Friday 12–10 pm; Saturday 12–10 pm. Closed on Sunday.
Yes, Extra Extra Pizza is open on Saturday, 12–10 pm.
Tap "Get the phone number" on this page to see the phone number for Extra Extra Pizza and call directly.
Extra Extra Pizza has a 4.7 out of 5 rating from 381 Google reviews.
Extra Extra Pizza lists: Sicilian-style pizza, Gluten-free pizza, Dine-in seating, Takeout, Beer and wine, Bread on the house. See the full list above.
Yes. Extra Extra Pizza is a pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY.
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Buffalo NY.
Claim this listing Feature my business