New York-style pizza in Plattsburgh, one size, cash only
Take-out New York-style pies on Margaret Street in Plattsburgh, NY, with large pepperoni, cheese and margarita pizzas and easy parking out back.
Reviewers note the shop is take-out only, so plan to pick up your pie.
Bring cash. Reviewers say the shop does not take other forms of payment.
Pies come in one size, and reviewers describe them as large.
Parking is available out back of the shop.
New York Pizza is a take-out pizza restaurant at 291 Margaret St in Plattsburgh, NY. The menu centers on New York-style pies sold in one size, with pepperoni and margarita among the choices regular customers mention. Parking is available out back, and the shop accepts cash only.
Reviewers describe the pies as large, with pepperoni evenly spread and consistent quality over time. Several mention friendly service and a fair price. The shop has 187 Google reviews averaging 4.4 stars, and one customer says the style is closer to the Bronx than to Queens.
Whole pies in the New York style, served in one size.
A pepperoni pie with the pepperoni spread evenly across the top, according to reviewers.
A margarita pie, which one customer ordered as half of a split pie.
A cheese pie, which one customer ordered as half of a split pie.
Orders are picked up to go. Cash is the accepted payment.
“Very good New York City Pizza! Friendly service. Great atmosphere (for take out). Make sure you bring cash. It is more Bronx style than the Queens style I grew up with. But, still very good! And easy parking out back.”
“This is the only place I will go for a pie. One size, cash only. My go to is pepperoni always. Bill has always been consistent with his pies with quality and taste. The pies are massive, the pepperoni appropriately spread.”
“Got a pizza there last week... half cheese and half margarita. It was excellent!! We'll be back!!”
New York Pizza is at 291 Margaret St, Plattsburgh, NY 12901, United States. Use the map on this page for directions.
Opening hours: Monday 4–7 pm; Tuesday 4–7 pm; Wednesday 11 am–7 pm; Thursday 11 am–7 pm; Friday 11 am–7 pm; Saturday 11 am–7 pm; Sunday 12–6 pm.
Yes, New York Pizza is open on Saturday, 11 am–7 pm.
Tap "Get the phone number" on this page to see the phone number for New York Pizza and call directly.
New York Pizza has a 4.4 out of 5 rating from 187 Google reviews.
New York Pizza lists: New York-style pizza, Pepperoni pizza, Margarita pizza, Cheese pizza, Take-out orders. See the full list above.
Yes. New York Pizza is a pizza restaurant in Plattsburgh, NY.
Claim this listing free to correct your details, or get featured at the top of Plattsburgh NY.
Claim this listing Feature my business