5 Underrated Bakeries in Downtown, Erie PA Worth Trying

This guide lists five bakeries in Downtown Erie, PA that are less well known than the bigger names but still well rated. Each one has a Google rating of 4.4 or higher with fewer than 400 reviews, so the list favors smaller shops that locals are still finding. Seven qualifying businesses were considered. The ranking uses Google ratings weighted by review count. Check hours before you go, since several shops keep short weekday or weekend schedules.

The list at a glance

  1. 1Majestic Baking Company★ 4.9 · 99 reviews · $10–20
  2. 2Bill's Bakery★ 4.9 · 91 reviews · $1–10
  3. 3Sontheimer's Country Bakery★ 4.8 · 196 reviews
  4. 4Art's Bakery Harborcreek★ 4.8 · 105 reviews · $10–20
  5. 5Bake Your Day★ 4.8 · 21 reviews · $1–10
#1

Majestic Baking Company

★ 4.9 (99 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop$10–20 per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

Majestic Baking Company is a bakery and cake shop at 1501 Walnut St in Erie, rated 4.9 on Google from 99 reviews. Listed hours cover Wednesday, Thursday and Friday from 11 am to 5 pm and Saturday from 10 am to 2 pm, with Monday, Tuesday and Sunday closed. Reviewers mention the sourdough and pepperoni bread, and say the crust is crunchy with plenty of flavor. Some report the shop was closed despite posted hours, so calling first is a good idea. Free street parking is listed.

Best for: Sourdough and traditional crusty loaves
Address
1501 Walnut St, Erie, PA 16502, United States
Hours
Fri 11 am–5 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 10 am–2 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 11 am–5 pm; Tue Closed; Wed 11 am–5 pm
#2

Bill's Bakery

★ 4.9 (91 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop$1–10 per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

Bill's Bakery is a takeaway bakery at 1825 W 26th St in Erie, rated 4.9 on Google from 91 reviews, with a price range of $1 to $10. It opens early, from 6 am to 1 pm from Tuesday through Saturday, and is closed on Sundays and Mondays. Reviewers mention Italian bread sliced or unsliced, pepperoni rolls, pepperoni rings and dinner rolls. One reviewer notes it is a shop rather than an eatery, and several describe the staff as friendly.

Best for: Italian bread and pepperoni rolls
Address
1825 W 26th St #2, Erie, PA 16508, United States
Hours
Fri 6 am–1 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 6 am–1 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 6 am–1 pm; Tue 6 am–1 pm; Wed 6 am–1 pm
#3

Sontheimer's Country Bakery

★ 4.8 (196 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop

Representative photo, not of this business.

Sontheimer's Country Bakery is at 3720 Sterrettania Road in Erie, rated 4.8 on Google from 196 reviews. Hours run Tuesday through Friday from 7:30 am to 5 pm and Saturday from 7 am to 1 pm, and the shop is closed on Sundays and Mondays. A wheelchair-accessible entrance and car park are listed. Reviewers mention fresh homemade baked goods, an extensive selection, orange crescent moon cakes and seasonal German donuts. One review notes the shop takes cash or check only.

Best for: Homemade pastries and cakes with a wide selection
Address
3720 Sterrettania Road, PA-832, Erie, PA 16506, United States
Hours
Fri 7:30 am–5 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 7 am–1 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 7:30 am–5 pm; Tue 7:30 am–5 pm; Wed 7:30 am–5 pm
#4

Art's Bakery Harborcreek

★ 4.8 (105 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop$10–20 per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

Art's Bakery Harborcreek is at 4625 Buffalo Rd in Erie, rated 4.8 on Google from 105 reviews, in the $10 to $20 price range. It is open every day, from 7 am to 8 pm on weekdays and 7 am to 6 pm on weekends. Listed features include coffee, takeaway, a free parking lot and SNAP/EBT payment. Reviewers mention the deli, the baked goods, sticky buns and a chocolate milk called pot o gold, and describe the prices as fair for the area.

Best for: Deli lunch and sticky buns
Address
4625 Buffalo Rd, Erie, PA 16510, United States
Hours
Fri 7 am–8 pm; Mon 7 am–8 pm; Sat 7 am–6 pm; Sun 7 am–6 pm; Thu 7 am–8 pm; Tue 7 am–8 pm; Wed 7 am–8 pm
#5

Bake Your Day

★ 4.8 (21 Google reviews)Bakery and Cake Shop$1–10 per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

Bake Your Day is at 9333 Tate Rd, Room 205, in Erie, rated 4.8 on Google from 21 reviews, with prices from $1 to $10. It serves breakfast and coffee and offers takeaway, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance. Hours run from 6 am to 2 pm on most weekdays and 6 am to noon on weekends, and it is closed on Thursdays. Reviewers mention custom decorated cakes that taste homemade, large soft cookies, pickle and cheese bagels, and fast, friendly service.

Best for: Custom cakes and large cookies
Address
9333 Tate Rd Rm 205, Erie, PA 16509, United States
Hours
Fri 6 am–2 pm; Mon 6 am–2 pm; Sat 6 am–12 pm; Sun 6 am–12 pm; Thu Closed; Tue 6 am–2 pm; Wed 6 am–2 pm

How we made this list

We looked at 7 bakeries in Downtown, Erie PA with a Google rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 20 reviews, then rated 4.4 or higher on Google but with fewer than 400 reviews. A rating from thousands of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful, so a new place with a few perfect scores does not jump the queue. Ratings and hours are from public Google listings on 11 October 2026 and can change. Nobody paid to be on this list.

Tips before you go

Frequently asked questions

Which is the highest-rated bakery on this list?

Majestic Baking Company ranks first, with a Google rating of 4.9 from 99 reviews. Bill's Bakery is second at 4.9 from 91 reviews.

Which bakeries in Downtown, Erie PA are open late?

None of these stays open past midnight. The latest to close is Art's Bakery Harborcreek, at 8 pm.

How much does it cost at these bakeries?

Google lists these price ranges per person: Majestic Baking Company $10–20; Bill's Bakery $1–10; Art's Bakery Harborcreek $10–20; Bake Your Day $1–10. The others do not list a price range.

Which of these have free parking?

Google lists free parking for Majestic Baking Company and Art's Bakery Harborcreek.

More guides for Downtown

Run a business in Downtown?

Get a fast website with your hours, menu, location and reviews. If your business is listed here and something is wrong, tell us and we fix it.

Email support@pagenearby.com