5 Underrated Restaurants in Downtown, Madison WI Worth Trying

This list covers underrated restaurants in Downtown Madison, WI. Businesses qualify with a Google rating of 4.4 or higher and fewer than 400 reviews, which surfaces places with strong scores and smaller review counts. Eight qualifying businesses were considered, and the five below are ordered by rating. It is written for diners who want something beyond the most-reviewed spots. Each entry covers hours, address and what reviewers say about the food and service.

The list at a glance

  1. 1Haven★ 4.8 · 340 reviews · $20–30
  2. 2Osteria Novella★ 4.8 · 221 reviews
  3. 3Molten Monkey - Best New Restaurant - 2025 - Madison Magazine★ 4.7 · 348 reviews
  4. 4It's Good For You★ 4.7 · 180 reviews
  5. 5Buck's Pizza★ 4.6 · 278 reviews
#1

Haven

★ 4.8 (340 Google reviews)Restaurant$20–30 per person

Representative photo, not of this business.

Haven at 430 W Gilman St is open daily from 11 am to 10 pm, with a listed price range of $20 to $30. It has a 4.8 rating from 340 Google reviews, and Google lists vegan and vegetarian options, small plates, a wine list and table service. Reviewers mention cajun fries, veggie dumplings, stir-fried yellow beef with a good amount of spice, braised pork noodles with a rich broth, and a cold noodle soup for warm days. One group rented a karaoke setup for a holiday party.

Best for: Noodles, dumplings and group parties
Address
430 W Gilman St, Madison, WI 53703, United States
Hours
daily 11 am–10 pm
#2

Osteria Novella

★ 4.8 (221 Google reviews)Italian restaurant

Representative photo, not of this business.

Osteria Novella, at 2903 University Ave, rates 4.8 from 221 Google reviews. It is open Monday through Saturday from 4 pm and closed on Sundays. Google lists wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating and toilet. Reviewers mention a bar seat experience that felt lively but not overwhelming, a birthday dinner with a muffaletta sandwich they called outstanding, a pepperoni pizza, and a bottle of house-made limoncello sent home with one guest. Peak dinner times were described as cramped.

Best for: Bar seats and a strong sandwich menu
Address
2903 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705, United States
Hours
Fri 4–10 pm; Mon 4–9 pm; Sat 4–10 pm; Sun Closed; Thu 4–9 pm; Tue 4–9 pm; Wed 4–9 pm
#3

Molten Monkey - Best New Restaurant - 2025 - Madison Magazine

★ 4.7 (348 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant

Representative photo, not of this business.

Molten Monkey is a pizza restaurant at 912 E Johnson St with a 4.7 rating from 348 Google reviews. It is open Wednesday through Sunday evenings and closed on Mondays and Tuesdays. Google does not list accessibility attributes for this business. Reviewers mention Detroit-style crusts, a buffalo-like Monkey Sauce that they described as a little sweeter, and a staff member who corrected a wrong-day pickup order quickly. Several reviewers describe a small, intimate room.

Best for: Detroit-style pizza with bold sauce
Address
912 E Johnson St, Madison, WI 53703, United States
Hours
Fri 4–9:30 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 4–9:30 pm; Sun 4–8:30 pm; Thu 4–8:30 pm; Tue Closed; Wed 4–8:30 pm
#4

It's Good For You

★ 4.7 (180 Google reviews)Pizza takeaway

Representative photo, not of this business.

It's Good For You is a pizza takeaway spot at 521 N Sherman Ave, rated 4.7 from 180 Google reviews. It is open Wednesday through Saturday from 5 to 9 pm and on Sundays from 4:30 to 8:30 pm, with Mondays and Tuesdays closed. Google lists wheelchair-accessible parking, entrance, seating and toilet. Reviewers mention wood-fired Neapolitan-style pies, a sweet and balanced tomato sauce, an open kitchen, and a patio that is popular in summer. A few reviewers said the crust was underdone in the center, and one noted a charge for vegan cheese.

Best for: Wood-fired pies and a summer patio
Address
521 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI 53704, United States
Hours
Fri 5–9 pm; Mon Closed; Sat 5–9 pm; Sun 4:30–8:30 pm; Thu 5–9 pm; Tue Closed; Wed 5–9 pm
#5

Buck's Pizza

★ 4.6 (278 Google reviews)Pizza restaurant

Representative photo, not of this business.

Buck's Pizza at 219 Cottage Grove Rd has a 4.6 rating from 278 Google reviews. It is open daily, from 4 pm to 9 or 10 pm depending on the day. Google lists wheelchair-accessible parking and entrance. Reviewers describe a thin crust that is thin without being cracker-crisp, and say it is a carryout-only shop with call-ahead pickup. The shop has no seating, so some guests ate at a bar next door. One regular has been ordering there for many years and drives over for the thin crust.

Best for: Thin crust for pickup
Address
219 Cottage Grove Rd, Madison, WI 53716, United States
Hours
Fri 4–10 pm; Mon 4–9 pm; Sat 4–10 pm; Sun 4–9 pm; Thu 4–9 pm; Tue 4–9 pm; Wed 4–9 pm

How we made this list

We looked at 8 restaurants in Downtown, Madison WI with a Google rating of 4.0 or higher and at least 20 reviews, then rated 4.4 or higher on Google but with fewer than 400 reviews. A rating from thousands of reviews counts for more than the same rating from a handful, so a new place with a few perfect scores does not jump the queue. Ratings and hours are from public Google listings on 11 October 2026 and can change. Nobody paid to be on this list.

Tips before you go

Frequently asked questions

Which is the highest-rated restaurant on this list?

Haven ranks first, with a Google rating of 4.8 from 340 reviews. Osteria Novella is second at 4.8 from 221 reviews.

Which restaurants in Downtown, Madison WI are open late?

None of these stays open past midnight. The latest to close is Haven, at 10 pm.

How much does it cost at these restaurants?

Google lists these price ranges per person: Haven $20–30. The others do not list a price range.

Which of these have free parking?

Google lists free parking for Haven.

More guides for Downtown

Run a business in Downtown?

Get a fast website with your hours, menu, location and reviews. If your business is listed here and something is wrong, tell us and we fix it.

Email support@pagenearby.com